Robert E. Scully, Jr.
Shareholder

Phone: (703) 790-1911
Fax: (703) 848-2530
RScully@reesbroome.com

Mr. Scully has practiced with Rees Broome, PC since 1984, concentrating in business torts litigation and general civil litigation. He is listed in Best Lawyers In America 2004-2005, in the category of commercial litigation. Mr. Scully was again named one of the “best lawyers in America” by the editors of the 2006 edition of Best Lawyers in America.

 
 

Practice Focus

Practice focuses on business litigation with substantial experience serving both as plaintiffs’ counsel and defense counsel in business tort cases (i.e., fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, interference with contract, defamation, unfair competition, trade secrets, and trademark infringement). He also has extensive litigation experience in the area of real estate, condominium and construction litigation. He is active in medical and legal professional practice dissolution litigation. He has testified as an expert witness in insurance coverage litigation over attorneys fees incurred in defense of intellectual property claims. He also has testified as an expert witness regarding Virginia legal ethics and Virginia standards of care in legal malpractice cases.

Representative Experience

Among Scully’s business tort cases, notable ones include:

• Represented the former Executive Vice-President of the largest union-owned life insurance company in congressional investigations of officers’ and directors’ alleged misconduct and ensuing corporate governance and ERISA litigation.
• Defended the selling shareholders of a regional fiber optic cable installation contractor against a twenty million dollar fraud claim made by a national energy conglomerate after its acquisition of the contractor.
• Defended the President of a national trade association against wrongful termination and defamation claims brought by its former director of legislative affairs.
• Defended a major technical employee outsourcing firm against interference with contract, defamation and business conspiracy claims brought by its former President.

Among Scully’s real estate, condominium and construction litigation, notable ones include:

• Obtained a declaratory judgment that a condominium developer’s failure to convert the top three floors of a 23-floor high-rise condominium into units within the statutory conversion period resulted in those 3 floors becoming permanent common elements.
• Walker v. Crigler, 976 F.2d 900 (4th Cir. 1992), establishing the law of non-delegable duty under the Fair Housing Act in the Fourth Circuit.

• Obtained an 8 million dollar judgment for extra work and an early completion bonus on behalf of two subcontractors against the general contractor and its payment bond surety on the Dulles Greenway Project. On appeal, the Fourth Circuit, as a matter of first impression under Virginia law, held that “pay- when-paid” conditions in performance and payment bonds must be express and applied the “prevention doctrine” to excuse the “pay-when-paid” condition. Moore Bros. Co. v. Brown & Root, Inc., 207 F.3d 717 (4th Cir. 2000).

Scully has been active in professional practice litigation:

• Defended a law firm against a suit brought by a departing partner who claimed to “own” a fifty million dollar contingent fee case.
• Defended a law firm against a declaratory judgment suit challenging its right to a fee in qui tam
litigation still under seal in federal court.
• Represented an intellectual property law firm in collecting a multi-million dollar fee from a national
corporation it defended in patent infringement litigation.

Education and Background

• J.D. Villanova University School of Law (1979)
• B.A. (with distinction), University of Virginia (1976)

Bar/Court Admissions

• Virginia (1979)
• Maryland (1986)
• District of Columbia (1981)
• U.S. District Courts and United States Courts of Appeal for those jurisdictions

Professional and Civic Involvement

• Member, Virginia State Bar
Chair, Board of Governors of the Litigation Section (2004-2005)
Past-Chair, Standing Committee on Lawyer Discipline (2002-2003)
Elected Representative, Virginia State Bar Council from the 19th Judicial Circuit (1997-2003)
• Regular Contributor, Virginia State Bar Litigation News and other publications.
• Presenter, Continuing Legal Education Programs
Virginia State Bar Mandatory Professionalism Course
Virginia CLE
Fairfax Bar Association
Community Associations Institute
Prolegia, the Minnesota Lawyers Mutual Risk Management Program